The Value Creation Protocol

Part III — The Core Framework Traps

Chapter 9

The Advertising Trap → Value-First Communication


When attention becomes currency, communication becomes combat

Klemen Hrovat, co-host of Let's Build Communication, joined me for this trap when I hosted a conversation on each of the ten in June 2025. On what happened to the way companies talk to people, he said:

"… then became a numbers game in a way influenced by the predictable revenue book, which kind of … design the framework, the process, how everything … should be kind of processed."

What used to be a dialogue. There were two people in it once. One asked something and the other answered. Klemen is describing the day one side stopped listening and started counting.

I have my own picture of it. It's like going to a networking event and just yelling out your name and value prop while everyone else continues talking to each other.

What this is

The Advertising Trap, as the Twelve Complexity Traps define it:

Fighting for attention through interruption rather than earning it through value delivery.

The name can mislead you. This is about more than paid ads. It's a way of standing toward people: we have something to say, and their attention is what's in the way. A cold email sequence fits. So does a post written to be seen more than to be used. The trap's fuller description says it plainly: communication focused on what you want to say rather than what people need to hear.

I think it made sense once. When there were only a few ways to reach people, paying for space to announce yourself was a reasonable thing to do. The ways to reach people multiplied. The habit stayed.

The methodology names the belief a trap breaks for five of the twelve, and this trap is not one of them; the belief to keep beside you here is Natural Value Flow over Artificial Control. That belief's shift runs "from value capture to value enablement," and this trap's own symptoms include talking about "capturing" attention.

What replaces it is Value-First Communication: "Communication should enable authentic discovery, not capture attention through manipulation." The shift runs from attention capture (interrupt, manipulate, convert) to natural discovery (inform, enable, support).

How to tell where you are

Klemen describes what it's like on the inside:

"Messaging now gets optimized for clicks … we want more of everything … and as a consequence we have more noise."

More of everything. Hold your own week up to that.

  • Take the last ten things your company sent or posted. For each one, ask who asked for it, and what a person could do with it that same day. Count the ones that were made mainly to get something from the reader.
  • Open the report your marketing is judged by. If it shows reach, impressions, opens and clicks, and nothing on it says what any of that did for the person on the other end, you're looking at the trap's scorecard.
  • Listen to the verbs. "Capture." "Target." "Blast." "Hit." Those are words for doing something to people.
  • Look at what comes back. Unsubscribes, calls sent to voicemail and one-word replies are people working to avoid you.
  • Compare this year's spend with last year's for the same response. If you're paying more to stand still, you're bidding against everyone else who is doing the same thing.
  • Ask what happens the month you stop paying. If the answer is that everything stops, none of that attention was ever yours.

What to do

  1. Sort what you send into three piles. Asked for: they requested it, or they write back to it. Useful unasked: a person could use it today even if they never buy from you. Interruption: it exists because you wanted to be seen. Stop one thing from the third pile before you make anything new.
  2. Find the conversations that are already happening. The people you serve are asking each other questions somewhere right now. Go there and write the questions down in their words. The alternative to yelling across the room is joining those existing conversations, contributing value, and allowing relationships to develop naturally.
  3. Make one thing that asks for nothing. Answer one of those questions all the way through. No call to action at the bottom, no form, no "learn more." Then make two more.
  4. Be easy to find when they go looking. People research on their own time. Put your answers where that research lands. The practice is to support research rather than disrupt it.
  5. Take the pressure out. Go through your templates and remove the countdowns and the "last chance" lines that aren't true. You want informed decisions, not impulsive reactions.
  6. Change the report. Keep reach on it if you need to. Put beside it what people did with what you sent and what they said about it. The next section is what to listen for.

If you pay to put something in front of people, hold it to the same test as everything else you send. Is it worth their attention when it gets there?

One of the Four Unified Views makes all of this easier. Seeing every communication a person has received, and what they actually ask, lets a team stop interrupting and say what people need to hear. That's the Unified Customer View, and Chapter 19 covers it.

How you know it worked

Here is the moment I trust most. I described it in 2025, talking about what I post online: "when you show up to a sales call and the first thing they do is thank you for the content while never having openly engaged with it...there is nothing better."

That person never pressed a button you could count. They read it, they used it, and they told you so themselves. That's the proof this chapter is after. Other forms of it:

  • They quote you back. Your words turn up in their questions.
  • They pass it on. Someone you've never met says a colleague sent them something of yours.
  • They come looking. They ask when the next one is, or they go and find the earlier ones.
  • They write back like a person. A real reply to something you sent, about their own situation.

Reach isn't on that list, and it can't stand in for anything that is. Even a count of thank-yous isn't enough alone. Ask what they did with it.

Where it goes wrong

Watch for the Lead Magnet Trap. Together the two do their damage at first contact, right where trust would have started. It begins the day the useful thing you made gets a form put in front of it so the team can show a return. The next chapter is about that form.

Four more to watch:

  • More, but helpful. Ten times the volume of useful posts is still Klemen's noise. This gets easier every month, because a machine will now write as much as you ask it to. Chapter 7 covers what happens when AI is used to do more of the old thing faster.
  • The pitch in a helpful costume. A useful headline with a sales argument underneath. Readers can tell by the second paragraph.
  • The last-touch report. If credit only goes to whatever a person touched right before they bought, the patient work never shows up, and it gets cut first. That's the Measurement Trap, in Chapter 14.
  • Everyone else is shouting. They are. Shouting louder costs more every quarter. It's also the one contest in this chapter you can simply leave.

Read further

Stop 1 of 6: What this is

Back to contents