The Value Era

Part V — The definition that already exists

Chapter 14

Only the person who received it


The last chapter ended on a table and asked you to read down the right-hand column. Five serious attempts. In four of them, the answer never gets as far as asking the person on the receiving end. In the one that's left, they're asked, and then a set of weights decides what their answer is worth.

This Part starts in that column.

At the end of Chapter 1 I promised you a definition and said not yet. In Chapter 3 I told you my company had finally written one down, and that I'd rather you met it after you'd seen what it has to survive. You've seen it now. Seven ways to fail, a clock, and five neighbors.

So here it is. I didn't write it for this book. It was already there, which is why this Part has the title it has.

What a person or organization can now do that they could not before. Not what they were sold, not what was produced for them, not a promise about the future — value is the real change in what someone can do, and only the person who received it can say it happened.

Read it twice. It's short.

One thing before we take it apart. This isn't the first principle itself. The first principle is what happened in Chapter 2, when you knew something of value took place at that door before anyone handed you a word for it. The page my company keeps on this says it in two sentences: "Value is recognized before it is defined. That is what makes it first." The definition came after the recognizing. It's what you get when you write the recognition down.

Three things it says

What someone can now do. The definition opens on a change in a person. Something is possible for them that wasn't.

You've met this idea already. In Chapter 4, behind the Human Development Index, there was Amartya Sen's thinking about what people are actually able to do and be. I said then that I didn't want to wave it away, and I'm not waving it away now. That opening stands on the same ground. I'm not claiming it's new. I'd be worried if it were.

Where the definition goes its own way is in who is speaking. The Index is compiled by statisticians, about whole countries. This is one person, saying what changed for them.

Three things it refuses. Then come three nots. I read each one as an answer to something earlier in this book.

Not what they were sold. That's price. Chapter 1 was about how price became the default stand-in for value. The definition steps past the stand-in before it does anything else.

Not what was produced for them. That's output. A thing can be made for you, delivered on time and exactly to spec, and change nothing about what you're able to do.

Not a promise about the future. That's the forecast. The two dates in Chapter 7 are dated claims about the future, and they may turn out to be right. Value, in this definition, is only ever something that already happened.

That mapping is mine. The sentence itself just lists the three.

Who can say. And then the clause this chapter is named for. Only the person who received it can say it happened.

That's a sixth row for the table. Who decides what counts? The person it reached. And in the right-hand column: asked, and nobody weights the answer.

In Chapter 1 I said Menger had it half right, and that this book would come back for that half. Here it is. He said value is nothing inherent in goods, and I agree with him. Value depends on a person. What happened after 1871 is that it got located in the wanting, before the exchange, where only a price could see it. This definition locates it afterwards, in what actually changed, where only the person it changed can see it.

Notice the verbs, too. Can now do. Happened. Nothing in the definition is a pile somebody sits on. Value here is a moment where something changed for someone. Then another moment, for someone else.

The door, from the holder's side

Chapter 2 gave you two doors, the one you were glad of and the one that made you jog. It also said something I left hanging on purpose. The person holding the door can't tell the difference. I told you I wasn't going to make that into a definition yet.

Now it is one. So stand on the other side this time.

Think about the last door you held. Somebody came through. Maybe they nodded.

Did value happen?

You don't know, and you can't. You saw a person walk through a door, and that's all a holder ever sees. The knowledge was never on your side of it.

In Chapter 12 I said I owed Walker one caution for this Part, and here's where I pay it. None of this is a grade on you. When the person who walked through says whether something happened for them, they aren't handing down a verdict on the one who held the door. Holding it was a decent thing to do either way. The definition only says where the answer lives.

What it already meets

Part II ended on a test, seven lines long, written the way I'd put it if I were in your seat. I said I thought there was a definition that clears most of it, and that I'd show you where it doesn't.

Here's the showing. I'll keep three things apart as I go: where the definition has an answer, where there's a rule around it that hasn't been proven out in the world yet, and where there's nothing.

It has to mean one thing. That was Same Word, Different Things. The test said that if two honest people can look at the same moment and not settle whether it counts, it isn't a definition yet. This definition's answer is that the two onlookers don't settle it. One person does, the one it happened to.

The six raters in Chapter 4 disagreed mostly on how to count, and also on what to count. The definition doesn't hire a seventh rater. It takes the question away from raters. Two people can walk through the same door and give you different answers, and neither is wrong, because neither one is rating the door.

What that costs is comparison. You don't get one number for the door. The next chapter says why I think that's the honest result. It's still a cost, and you should see it as one.

It can't leave people out. That was Counting Only Some People. The definition draws no line ahead of time around who counts. Anyone it reached can say, and that's more than a survey can promise. But read the definition again. It doesn't make anyone go and ask. Whoever keeps a record of value still decides whose moments get written into it, and a record can leave people out as quietly as a survey can. So the definition draws no line, and it offers no protection against a line drawn by whoever keeps the book.

It can't turn back into money. That was Back Into Money. This definition starts by refusing price, there are no points in it to pile up, and the vocabulary around it gives money a specific place. You met the name in Chapter 10: a Value Wake. The entry says, "Money is one wake; so is a capability that keeps paying off, or a relationship that deepens." And a wake is "recorded last, never first, and never the thing you steer by."

So money isn't the villain here, and it isn't nothing. It's real, it comes after, and it's one of several things that can come after. That's a rule. I can show you the rule. I can't show you ten years of people keeping to it when cash is short.

It can't be something you win by chasing. That was Playing the Number. Look at the tense of the definition. Can say it happened. Not a promise about the future. Value read this way can be seen afterwards and can't be aimed at ahead of time, and there's no score in it to chase. That closes the easy route. It doesn't close every route. People can learn to perform gratitude as well as they perform anything else, and Chapter 16 has to deal with that.

Somebody has to actually use it. That was Nobody Uses It, and here the definition comes up short. No government, board or budget office answers to it, and nothing in the definition can make one. A person can use it tomorrow, for a decision that matters to them, without waiting for any institution. I think that's worth a lot. It still isn't what Chapter 6 was asking for.

Checking it has to be cheap. That was Too Costly to Check, and it's open. Asking the person who received it is slow, and it asks something of them. Nothing I've shown you so far makes it cheaper. That's Chapter 16.

It has to outlast whoever started it. That was Held Up by One Person. I said in Chapter 6 that this one points at me. Somebody has to keep the definition, fixing a word when a word turns out to be wrong, and right now the wording changes on my say. That's Chapter 17.

So that's the count. An answer or a rule for four of the seven, with the gaps I've named. One it plainly doesn't meet. Two open. "Clears most of it" was fair, though not by much, and I'd rather hand you this than a definition that claims to survive everything.

"Only the person who received it can say it happened" leaves two practical questions hanging. Say it in what words? And who writes it down, so it's still there next year?

That's the next chapter.

Back to contents