The Value Era

Part I — The word is empty

Chapter 1

The price of everything


Ask ten people what something is worth and most of them will tell you what it costs.

That isn't a mistake on their part. It's the answer we were all handed. If you want to know what a house is worth, you look up what houses like it sold for. If you want to know what a company is worth, you multiply the share price by the number of shares. If you want to know what a person's work is worth, you look at the paycheck. We say "value" and we reach for a price, every time, without noticing we did it.

They weren't always the same word. For most of the history we have written down, people treated value and price as two things and argued about how they were connected. And there is a short stretch of years where you can watch the connection flip.

Three men who never met

Between 1871 and 1874, three economists published three books. William Stanley Jevons in England, The Theory of Political Economy, 1871. Carl Menger in Austria, Principles of Economics, the same year. Léon Walras, writing from Switzerland, Elements of Pure Economics, 1874. They worked separately. None of them knew what the other two were doing.

All three landed in the same place.

Before them, the usual account ran in one direction. What a thing was worth came from what went into it: the work, the land, the materials. Adam Smith called labor the "real measure." People disagreed about the details for centuries, but the direction held. Cost shaped value, and value shaped price.

The three of them turned it around. Value, they said, isn't in the thing at all. It's in how much someone wants one more of it. Menger wrote it as plainly as anyone has. In the English translation by James Dingwall and Bert F. Hoselitz: "Value is therefore nothing inherent in goods, no property of them, but merely the importance that we first attribute to the satisfaction of our needs, that is, to our lives and well-being…"

Read that one slowly, because half of it is right, and this book is going to come back for that half. Value isn't sitting inside the object. It depends on a person. Hold on to that.

Here's the half that did the damage. Once value lived in what people want, the only place anyone could see it was in what they paid. So the arrow flipped. Yair Kaldor, writing on the Economic Sociology and Political Economy site in 2019, puts it this way: "Instead of labor, land and capital determining value, they insisted that it is the value of a good – now equated with its price – that determines the value of labor, land and capital."

Now equated with its price. Five words, in the middle of a sentence. That's the hinge.

Value used to be the thing that explained price. After 1874 it started becoming another name for it.

How a question gets dropped

Nobody announced this. I don't think anybody decided it. It happened the way most big things happen, one reasonable step at a time.

The first step: if value is the satisfaction someone gets, you'd like to measure the satisfaction. For a while economists tried to treat it as a quantity. That didn't hold up. In 1934 John Hicks and R.G.D. Allen showed you could get by with rankings alone. A person prefers this to that, and you never have to say by how much. Four years later Paul Samuelson published a way to work from the choices alone. Watch what a person picks, and build the theory on that.

Each step made the math cleaner. Each step also moved the thing being studied a little further out of the room. By the middle of the twentieth century, mainstream economics had a very good method for studying prices and choices, and no working idea of value apart from them. A 2025 history of value theory, written by four property-valuation researchers and crediting Jonathan Levy's The Real Economy, says that neoclassical economics "has also abandoned a subject matter for a method."

No shade on the people who did it. They were solving real problems, and price is a remarkable instrument. It's public. It's a number. Two strangers can agree on it without agreeing on anything else. If you had to pick one stand-in for value, and you needed it to work across a whole economy, you'd probably pick price too.

But a stand-in is still a stand-in. And once the stand-in is the only thing anyone writes down, people forget there was something it was standing in for.

The books followed

Accounting went the same way, and here you don't have to take a historian's word for it. You can read the rule.

The international accounting standard on fair value defines it as "the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date." The American standard says the same thing in nearly the same words. Fair value is an exit price. What could you sell it for, today.

The older method, historical cost, is what you paid for it. So the books offer two ways to say what something is worth: the price you paid, or the price you could get. Neither one defines value as anything other than a price.

You can see what that leaves out. Baruch Lev, an accounting professor at NYU, points at a strange one: "if you buy a house, this is an asset. If you buy a patent... it is also an asset. But if you internally generate that same patent, that's an expense." Same patent. Buy it, and it has a price, so it counts. Build it yourself, and it never had a price, so on the books it's a cost.

It runs all the way up. The number we use to say how a whole country is doing has the same blind spot, and the people who compile it say so. The U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, in its own look back at GDP: "Unpaid work done inside the home is not included." Raising a child. Caring for a parent. Cooking dinner for people you love. No price, so no entry.

You don't need a national account to see it, either. Somebody held a door for you this week. The price of that was zero. You'd have a hard time telling me nothing happened.

None of this means price is wrong. It means price became the dominant, default definition of value, and a default has edges. Anything that never gets a price sits outside them.

Why it matters now

For a hundred and fifty years we could live with that. Most of what we needed to coordinate did have a price, and the things that didn't, we handled the old way, between people.

Here's what changed. Some of the people building the most powerful technology of our lifetimes are now saying, out loud, that price itself is on its way out.

In an interview The Economist released in July 2026, Elon Musk told Zanny Minton Beddoes: "Money won't matter in 2036." Pressed on it, he said that if goods and services were that abundant, "what do you need money for in that case?" About a month earlier he had posted the short version: "Mass & energy will take the place of dollars."

You don't have to believe the date. Plenty of serious people don't, and we'll hear from them in Part III. I'm not asking you to be afraid of it either. I'm asking you to notice what the claim leaves open.

Mass and energy are an answer to "what will machines trade in?" They aren't an answer to "what is a person worth?" And for a century and a half, the default answer to that second question has been a price: a wage, a salary, a net worth. If that's the answer we've been using, and the people building the future say it's going away, then we're about to find out what we have underneath it.

Where does your brain go with that?

Mine goes here. We don't have a second answer ready. Not because nobody is smart enough. Because we stopped working on the question in 1874.

What got left behind

So let me name what was abandoned, because the rest of this book is about getting it back.

It wasn't a theory. Theories of value came and went long before 1871, and they'll keep coming. What got left behind was the idea that value comes first. That it's the thing prices are trying to point at, the thing work is for, the thing everything else descends from.

Value as THE first principle.

I'm going to give you a definition of it. Not yet. A definition handed over in Chapter 1 is a slogan, and you've had enough of those. First I want to show you that you already know what it is, and that people knew long before anybody put a price on anything.

Back to contents