The Value Creation Protocol

Part V — Putting it to work

Chapter 22

What this rests on


This chapter claims less than you might expect, and that's on purpose.

It would be easy to fill these pages with a list of sciences and a line that says the research supports us. I'm not going to do that. A claim with no name on it can't be checked, and you should be able to check anything in this handbook.

So here are four published sources, each one named, each one something you can read yourself. For each I'll say what it says, which part of this handbook it stands next to, and where its support stops.

What this is

Donella Meadows, "Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System" (1999). Meadows was a systems analyst, and this essay is her list of the places in a system where "a small shift in one thing can produce big changes in everything." Three things on her list sit next to this handbook.

The first is information. She writes: "Missing feedback is one of the most common causes of system malfunction. Adding or restoring information can be a powerful intervention, usually much easier and cheaper than rebuilding physical infrastructure." And then: "It's important that the missing feedback be restored to the right place and in compelling form." That is close to what Chapter 19 asks of a unified view: the context a person needs, where they already work.

The second is a system's ability to change itself. "Insistence on a single culture shuts down learning," she writes. And: "Encouraging variability and experimentation and diversity means 'losing control.'" That stands next to the Conformity Trap and to the belief this handbook calls Emergence over Predictability.

The third is the one she ranks near the top, the paradigm a system comes out of. "Paradigms are the sources of systems." That stands next to Chapter 21's advice to do the Mindset work first. Among the unstated assumptions of our own culture, she lists this one: "Money measures something real and has real meaning (therefore people who are paid less are literally worth less)." The Value Era is a whole book about that assumption.

Where the support stops: Meadows says so herself. "It's dangerous to generalize about them. What you are about to read is a work in progress. It's not a recipe for finding leverage points."

Mark Granovetter, "The Strength of Weak Ties," American Journal of Sociology (1973). Granovetter studied how information and opportunity move between people. His conclusion runs against instinct: "weak ties, often denounced as generative of alienation … are here seen as indispensable to individuals' opportunities and to their integration into communities; strong ties, breeding local cohesion, lead to overall fragmentation."

Read that last clause with a department in mind. A close team with few bridges to anyone else is cohesive locally and fragmented overall. That stands next to the belief called Wholeness over Fragmentation, and next to Chapter 23, where practitioners connect across organizations.

Where the support stops: his subject was personal networks, how information and opportunity travel through them and how communities organize. He also calls his own model "a very limited step" and "a fragment of a theory." The step from his paper to your org chart is mine to defend, not his.

Amy Edmondson, "Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams," Administrative Science Quarterly (1999). Edmondson defines a term that gets used loosely: "Team psychological safety is defined as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking." She studied 51 work teams in a manufacturing company and reports that "team psychological safety is associated with learning behavior."

That stands next to the Conformity Trap and the Authority Trap. A team where it isn't safe to say "this isn't working" learns less, on Edmondson's measure, whatever its process says.

Where the support stops: one company, and an association. It's a careful study. It isn't a law.

Richard Ryan and Edward Deci, "Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being," American Psychologist (2000). Ryan and Deci review the research behind "three innate psychological needs—competence, autonomy, and relatedness—which when satisfied yield enhanced self-motivation and mental health and when thwarted lead to diminished motivation and well-being." They also report what undermines the motivation people bring on their own: "not only tangible rewards but also threats, deadlines, directives, pressured evaluations, and imposed goals diminish intrinsic motivation".

That stands next to the belief called Empowerment over Learned Helplessness, and next to the Measurement Trap, where pressure and evaluation stand in for meaning.

Where the support stops: it's a review. It ranges across health care, education, work, sport, religion and psychotherapy, so work is one setting among several. It tells you about people. It doesn't tell you this methodology works.

None of the four tested the Value-First methodology. They are published work that four of its positions line up with. The rest of this handbook rests on practice and on beliefs that are stated as beliefs. The proof that it works for you is the test at the end of every chapter: what the person who received the value says.

How to tell where you are

  • A slide in your last strategy deck says "research shows" or "studies show," and nobody in the room could say which research.
  • A practice gets defended as "best practice," and when you ask whose, there's no answer.
  • A statistic gets repeated in your company and nobody knows where it started.
  • You catch yourself saying one of these.

What to do

  1. Ask for the name. When someone says the research shows, ask whose research and where it's published. Ask it kindly. You're looking for the source, not a fight.
  2. Read the original. The Meadows essay is free to read online at the Donella Meadows Project, and it's written for anyone. The other three are journal articles. Each is clear in its opening pages about what was studied.
  3. Keep the author's limits attached. If the study was 51 teams in one company, say that when you cite it.
  4. Hold each one against something real. Pick one sign from one chapter of this handbook and see whether the source describes what you see in your own company.
  5. Treat everything else here as something to test. With your customers, in your own work, on the terms each chapter gives you.

How you know it worked

The person you were making a case to can check it without you. They come back having read the source. Sometimes they come back disagreeing with how you used it, and they can point to the page. That's it working.

A deck with more citations doesn't count. What counts is whether the person on the other side of the table could follow your claim back to where it came from.

Where it goes wrong

None of the Twelve Complexity Traps is named for this, but the Authority Trap is its nearest neighbor. That trap is centralizing control in ways that prevent the distributed intelligence organizations need. An unnamed "research shows" works the same way in a conversation. It ends the discussion from above and gives nobody anything they can examine. A named source does the opposite. It hands the other person what they need to decide for themselves.

The other way it goes wrong is stretching. A study of teams in one manufacturing company becomes "science says." A paper about how people hear of jobs becomes proof of an org design. When you feel yourself stretching, say where the source stops, the way this chapter tries to.

Read further

Stop 1 of 6: What this is

Back to contents