The Value Era

Part II — Every attempt to refill it has failed, in seven ways

Chapter 5

Back into money, gamed on arrival


Say the number is good. Everyone agrees what it measures, how, and for whom. The problems in Chapter 4 are solved.

Two things can happen to a number like that once it matters. Sometimes it turns back into money. And sooner or later, somebody starts playing it.

The score that isn't there

Start with the most famous non-money score in the world, the one almost everybody has heard of: China's social credit score. One number for every citizen, built from how you behave, deciding what you're allowed to do.

It doesn't exist.

Jamie Horsley, writing for Brookings in 2018, put it flatly: "There is no such thing as a national “social credit score.”" What does exist is patchier and more ordinary. In her words, "A few dozen towns and cities in China, as well as private companies running loyalty-type programs for their customers, do currently compute scores, primarily to determine rewards or access to various programs."

The private one people usually have in mind is Ant Financial's Sesame Credit. Horsley describes it as a program "which gives rewards on various platforms and easier access to credit," and notes that it "was often cited as a precursor of a planned government program, despite being a private enterprise." In 2015 China's central bank let eight companies, Sesame Credit among them, apply for licenses to become official credit agencies. "None of those companies qualified."

So follow what happened. An idea that sounded like a new way to see a person's trustworthiness, something beyond a bank balance, never became the national score people imagine. It stayed a private rating, and what the rating gets you is perks. A 2021 report from MERICS, a European research institute that studies China, said the city-run scoring systems "resemble incentivised loyalty programmes like those run by airlines."

That's the first failure in this chapter. I'll call it Back Into Money. People imagined a measure of trustworthiness that sat above money. What exists is rewards on platforms, access to credit, and the airline-style perks of a few dozen towns and cities. The measure, wherever it is real, ends up as a way of doing business.

The one that lasted

There's a more respectable version of the same story, and it's worth telling because it's the success.

In 1934 two Swiss businessmen, Werner Zimmermann and Paul Enz, set up a way for firms to trade with each other in a unit of their own. They called it WIR.

It's still running. Of everything in this part of the book, it's the one that clearly lasted.

And here is how it lasted. It was granted a banking license in 1936, and it has been a bank ever since.

I don't say that to take anything away from it. My reading, and it is only a reading, is that WIR survived by moving inside the money system and becoming a regulated part of it. The alternative that worked is the one that stopped being an alternative.

The doorman

Back to the door for a minute. This is imagined, like the lobby in the last chapter.

Now there's a man whose job is to hold it. He's good at it. You walk up, he opens it, and as you pass you hand him a dollar.

Something changed, and you can feel it even if it's hard to say what. It's the same door. It's the same four seconds. The coffee still doesn't spill. But the stranger who noticed you is now a man doing his job, and the thanks you would have given is now a tip. The act went back into money, and one of the things you got at the door in Chapter 2 got quieter.

Take it one step further. Suppose the building decides door-holding is good and starts rewarding it. A point for every door. A prize at the end of the month.

You know what happens next. People hold doors nobody needs. They hold them for people twenty yards away. They hold them for people who aren't coming in. The count goes up and up, and the thing the count was for, somebody with their hands full getting through, doesn't change at all.

That's the second failure. I'll call it Playing the Number.

Where it has already happened

The doorman is made up. The pattern isn't. It has been documented in place after place where a count started to matter.

Scientists are judged partly on how often other scientists cite their work, and there's a single figure, the h-index, that sums it up. In 2011 two researchers, Bartneck and Kokkelmans, ran a simulation and concluded that authors "can considerably inflate" their own h-index by citing themselves.

Programmers size up software projects on GitHub partly by how many users have given them a star. A team of researchers went through the site's records from 2019 to 2024. The title of their paper is the finding: "Six Million (Suspected) Fake Stars in GitHub." They report that this activity has "rapidly surged in 2024," and that most of the fake stars were used to promote what they call "short-lived phishing malware repositories." A sign of quality had become something you could fake in bulk.

Programmers also answer each other's questions on Stack Overflow, and earn a reputation score for good answers. Another team read 1,697 discussion posts about cheating on the site and found "four different types of reputation fraud scenarios," among them "voting rings where communities form to upvote each other repeatedly on similar posts."

Most of the people inside these systems never set out to wreck anything. A citation count was a decent sign of good science until careers hung on it. A star was a decent sign of good software until projects were sized up by it. The moment a count can be aimed at, somebody aims at it.

What this chapter leaves you with

Two more failures. Every attempt in this chapter to stand outside money ended up inside it: the scores as perks and credit, WIR as a bank. And a measure that works gets played the minute playing it pays.

Both of those assume something I haven't questioned yet. They assume the measure was in use. Somebody had taken it up, and that is why it was worth turning into business or worth gaming.

What about the measures that were good, and honest, and that nobody took up at all?

Back to contents