Part II — Every attempt to refill it has failed, in seven ways
Chapter 6
Nobody to use it, nobody to carry it
So far the measures in this part of the book failed because of something in the measure. It meant different things to different people, or it left people out, or it slid back into money, or it got played.
This chapter is about measures that were good. Careful, honest, sometimes brilliant. They failed anyway, and the reason was never in the measure. It was in a question nobody asked at the start: who has to carry this, and what does it cost them?
The best-qualified attempt anyone has made
In 2008 the president of France, Nicolas Sarkozy, asked a commission of economists to work out what a country should measure besides its total output. It was chaired by Joseph Stiglitz, with Amartya Sen as adviser and Jean-Paul Fitoussi as coordinator. Two of the three are Nobel laureates. If you were picking people for this job, you would pick them.
Their report came out in 2009. It's good. One line near the front could stand as the motto for this whole part of the book: "What we measure affects what we do; and if our measurements are flawed, decisions may be distorted."
It didn't offer one new number to replace the old one. It recommended a set of them, read side by side like the gauges in a car. And it was honest about its own limits: "The report is about measurement rather than policies."
That sentence is where the trouble starts. The commission could say what to measure. It couldn't make anyone use it.
What happened next depends on who you ask, and I want to give you both halves.
It changed what statisticians publish. The European Union's research center credits the report with helping to shape the OECD's well-being framework. And one country went further than publishing. Italy's national statistics office describes it this way: "The Law no. 163/2016, which reformed the Italian Budget law, introduced a limited number of indicators of equitable and sustainable well-being, selected from the Bes framework, into the cycle of economic and budget planning." That's real, and Italy deserves the credit.
And yet. A later look back at the commission's work, by the French researchers Florence Jany-Catrice and Dominique Méda, concluded that "the dominant position of GDP has scarcely been dented at all, even though…" the limits of GDP had been pointed out many times, the commission's report among them.
Both things are true. The indicators get published. In Italy they sit beside the budget. They don't decide it. The number that moves markets and ends careers is still the old one.
I'll call this failure Nobody Uses It. It may be the hardest of the seven to look at, because nothing went wrong. The work was excellent. It was published, praised and cited. It never became the thing anyone had to answer to.
Somebody has to check
Suppose a measure does find a home. Somebody takes it up and means it. Now a second cost shows up. Somebody has to check.
One of the best-known ways of putting a figure on social good is called Social Return on Investment. A charity or a program works out what changed for the people it serves and reports the result as a ratio, in money. You'll notice where that ends up, after the last chapter.
A review of forty SROI studies in public health found use of the method declined after 2011, probably, its authors say, because the government stopped encouraging it or because of "the inherent challenges… including cost, time and the people- and expertise-dependent nature of the methodology."
Nobody seems to have published what one of these costs all in. The one price on record is narrower. If you want an independent body to check a finished report, the standard fee in 2026 is £1,350, or £1,650 if you can't wait for the next round. That is for checking the report. It isn't for doing the work the report describes.
Think about what that means for something small. If the good you did was a few seconds at a door, or an hour with someone who needed it, a check that costs four figures isn't a check. It's the end of the idea.
I'll call this one Too Costly to Check. When confirming that something of value happened costs more than what happened, people stop confirming.
You can watch the same cost land on volunteers. Communities in many countries set up local exchange systems, usually called LETS, where neighbors traded favors and kept a ledger of who owed what. Somebody had to keep that ledger. A study of the London schemes found that the administration took considerable resources to keep going. In the Czech Republic, organizers' exhaustion was one of the main reasons schemes closed. One researcher wrote in 2002 that the movement had hit a stumbling block.
Nobody in those schemes was doing anything wrong either. They ran out of evenings.
Held up by one person
The last failure is the most human.
In 1991 a man named Paul Glover started a local currency in Ithaca, New York, called the Ithaca Hour. By 1998 about $63,000 worth had been issued and some 300 businesses accepted them.
Glover didn't just print the notes. He was the one who went around town connecting people, and helping businesses find ways to spend the Hours they had taken in.
In 2005 he moved away. The currency didn't collapse, and I want to be accurate about that, because it's usually told as a collapse. In 2007 there were about $120,000 in Hours out, at more than 600 businesses. But its use declined, and accounts differ on why. One account has some businesses taking in more Hours than they could find a way to spend, which is the problem Glover used to help with; he was gone. I can't tell you how much of the decline that explains. But look at what his leaving tells you. The system needed somebody to carry it around town, and it had one somebody.
I'll call this Held Up by One Person. And notice which of our examples escaped it. WIR, from the last chapter, has run since 1934 and no longer depends on the two men who started it. It did that by becoming a bank, an institution that doesn't depend on any one person showing up.
Which leaves an uncomfortable pair of choices. Stay personal, and last as long as one person does. Or become an institution, and find yourself back inside the money system.
I should say that this one points at me too. I'll deal with it honestly near the end of the book.
What a real definition would have to survive
That's seven. Let me put them in one place, in plain words, because you're about to need them.
We've now watched a lot of serious people try to put something in money's place, and we know how it went. So before anybody hands you a definition of value, mine included, you're entitled to hold it up against what you've just seen. Here's the test, as I'd put it if I were in your seat.
It has to mean one thing. If two honest people look at the same moment and can't settle whether it counts, it isn't a definition yet.
It can't leave people out. If it only works by deciding ahead of time who gets counted, it's measuring the count, not the people.
It can't turn back into money. If its natural resting place is a price or a pile of points, it was a price all along.
It can't be something you win by chasing. If aiming at it makes it go up without anything real changing, it will be played.
Somebody has to actually use it. Not publish it. Use it, for a decision that matters to them.
Checking it has to be cheap. If confirming that it happened costs more than what happened, nobody will confirm.
It has to outlast whoever started it. Me included.
Seven ways to fail. That's the bar.
I think there's a definition that clears most of it, and I'll show you where it doesn't. But first I owe you an answer to a question you may be asking by now, which is why any of this is urgent. Economics has gotten along without an answer since 1874. Why can't this wait?
Because there's a clock.